What Happened To The Science Shows?
Several people have sent me links recently to an article at The Onion lamenting the sad state of science programming on television these days. Interestingly, The Onion didn't even need to add much satire to the article.
I have fond memories of watching shows like The Operation on The Discovery Channel back in the early 1990's. A typical episode would introduce the viewer to a patient, describe his condition, explain the surgery he was about to receive, show about 30 minutes of surgery footage, and close with a post-op visit with the patient. The surgery segments were fairly graphic, as one might expect, but at the end of the program I'd learned a few things.
These days, I'm more likely to find a show purporting to prove t hat JFK was assassinated by a conspiracy between the Freemasons and the Russian Mafia because he was getting ready to expose the truth about the Roswell aliens and their connection to the destruction of Atlantis.
It's absurd.
A quick glance at the program lineup for The Discovery Channel today shows eight episodes of Cash Cab, six episodes of Verminators, four episodes of Man vs. Wild and a handful of other programs (including one which I initially misread as Solving History with Oily Steeds...). Not much here I'd really call science. The only really sciency program I can come up with on Discovery these days is Mythbusters, and even as cool as that show is, it sometimes veers a little too far into spectacle.
A check of The Learning Channel's schedule paints a similar picture - lots of shows about large families, fashion, and being pregnant, but scarcely a scintilla of scientific programming.
At this point, I'm almost scared to look at The History Channel, but here we go...
Let's see - a lot of infomercials, UFO programs, and Monster Quest episodes (although I may have to check out the episode on the Hillbilly Beast of Kentucky...), but only a little in the way of History. (I know. The History Channel was never really positioned as a science channel, but it used to be a lot more geared towards educational programming than the infotational material it shows now.)
There is really only one good place to go for science programming these days - PBS.
PBS runs some excellent, well-researched programs such as Scientific American Frontiers, hosted by Alan Alda, and the venerable NOVA.
I wish there were more offerings like these...
-Jay

February 7th, 2010 - 16:15
Ahhh, yes. The good old days when a National Geographic Special on PBS, narrated by Alexander Scorby, of course, was so truly special that it caused real ratings drops for the three other networks.
There was a window of time when we often recorded television shows for fear of seeing them again. It now appears that many are continualy recycled reruns on some channel or otherwise available. Sturgeon’s Law (or Revelation for the true pickers of nit) still applies.
February 9th, 2010 - 13:25
I would steer you towards a site like mvgroup.org where you can find documentaries of many subjects, but it would be a little self promoting and possibly not rhyme with your ethical framework.
Registration is free, and there is no ratio.
February 9th, 2010 - 13:26
Oh, and we have a lot of cool BBC sciency stuff
February 9th, 2010 - 14:16
Since the URL “mvgroup.org” takes you to a page requiring signing up to do anything other than sign up, with no links to information about the site or group, FAQs, rules, etc., I guess I won’t be signing up. Your suggestion that there might be ethical problems only strengthens my impression that it is probably not for me. Regardless of its other virtues, whatever they may be, mvgroup.org really does not succeed as a web site.
February 9th, 2010 - 14:54
I’m going to go with sirhcton on this one.
A lot of the BBC and PBS programs are freely available at the source without ever needing to worry about ethical issues.